The Ultimate Combined 11: Treble-Winning Manchester United 1999 vs Liverpool Team

TLDRA discussion between former Manchester United and Liverpool players on who would make the ultimate combined 11 between the treble-winning Manchester United team of 1999 and the current Liverpool team.

Key insights

🥅The goalkeeper position is a tough choice between Peter Schmeichel and Alisson Becker, both considered as world-class goalkeepers in their prime.

🎯Trent Alexander-Arnold is chosen as the right-back for his exceptional impact and influence on the current Liverpool team.

🛡️Dennis Irwin is favored as the left-back due to his versatility and defensive prowess.

Roy Keane is an undisputed choice as the central midfield player for his leadership, work rate, and overall contribution to the Manchester United team.

David Beckham is acknowledged as one of the greatest midfielders, possessing exceptional technical abilities and work rate.

Q&A

How do the players justify Gary Neville's exclusion from the combined 11?

The decision to exclude Gary Neville from the combined 11 is based on Trent Alexander-Arnold's influential role in the current Liverpool team.

Was David Beckham's fame a distraction for his teammates?

No, David Beckham's teammates were fully aware of his fame and celebrity status but greatly valued his dedication, work rate, and contributions to the team.

Why is Ryan Giggs not included in the ultimate combined 11?

While Ryan Giggs is highly regarded as one of the greats of the Premier League, the competition for the left-sided attacking position is tough, and other players were favored for their consistency and influence.

What qualities make Roy Keane a standout choice for the central midfield position?

Roy Keane's leadership, work rate, and overall impact on the Manchester United team make him an undisputed choice for the central midfield position in the ultimate combined 11.

Why is Dennis Irwin chosen as the left-back over other contenders?

Dennis Irwin's versatility and defensive prowess, coupled with his consistent performances, make him the preferred choice as the left-back in the ultimate combined 11.

Timestamped Summary

00:00Introduction to discussing the ultimate combined 11 between the treble-winning Man United team of 1999 and the current Liverpool team.

00:23Debate on the goalkeeper position: Peter Schmeichel vs Alisson Becker.

04:02Comparison of right-back options: Trent Alexander-Arnold vs Gary Neville.

06:05Discussion on left-back options: Dennis Irwin vs Andrew Robertson.

07:55Evaluation of central midfield players: Roy Keane and David Beckham.