The Problems with Episode Nine’s Storytelling

TLDRThe introduction of Emperor Palpatine in Episode nine feels forced and fails to provide a satisfactory explanation. The movie lacks coherence and fails to address important plot points. The characters' motivations and actions are unclear. The pacing and editing are choppy. The story relies heavily on nostalgia and callbacks to previous films. Overall, the storytelling falls short in delivering a compelling and cohesive narrative.

Key insights

😕The introduction of Emperor Palpatine feels forced and serves as a nostalgic callback.

🤔The movie fails to explain important plot points, leaving the audience confused.

🎬The pacing and editing are choppy, making the story feel disjointed.

⚔️The motivations and actions of the characters are unclear and inconsistent.

🔙The film heavily relies on nostalgia and callbacks to previous films.

Q&A

Why is Emperor Palpatine introduced in Episode nine?

Emperor Palpatine is introduced to appeal to fans who disliked the previous film and to create a nostalgic connection to the original trilogy.

Does the movie address important plot points?

No, the movie fails to provide explanations for key plot elements, leaving the audience confused and unsatisfied.

What is the main issue with the storytelling?

The main issue is the lack of coherence and clarity in character motivations, actions, and plot progression.

Why does the movie rely so heavily on nostalgia?

The film uses nostalgia as a way to appeal to fans and recreate the feel of the original trilogy.

Is the pacing and editing well-executed?

No, the pacing and editing are choppy, leading to a disjointed and unsatisfying viewing experience.

Timestamped Summary

00:12The introduction of Emperor Palpatine in Episode nine feels forced and fails to provide a satisfactory explanation.

00:32The movie lacks coherence and fails to address important plot points, leaving the audience confused.

01:13The pacing and editing are choppy, making the story feel disjointed and unsatisfying.

02:06The motivations and actions of the characters are unclear, leading to inconsistency and confusion.

02:25The film heavily relies on nostalgia and callbacks to previous films, which can overshadow the storytelling.