The Power of Scott Pilgrim as Anime

🎌Scott Pilgrim takes off is a true anime that was made in Japan with the intent to reach a Japanese audience.

🤝The distinction between co-productions and outsourced cartoons is vague and arbitrary, leading to inconsistencies in defining what qualifies as anime.

🌎Excluding certain co-productions from the anime database can cause problems and limit the representation of significant works in the industry.

👥The Western fandom's perception of what qualifies as anime often overlooks the intentions and creative contributions of Japanese industry talent.

🔍A more inclusive approach should be taken in defining anime, considering the cultural context, production process, and artistic style rather than strict categorizations.

Why is the categorization of Scott Pilgrim as anime important?

—The categorization of Scott Pilgrim as anime is important because it highlights the growing influence of Japanese animation techniques and storytelling in international productions. Recognizing it as anime acknowledges the contributions of Japanese industry talent and expands the definition of what qualifies as anime.

Why is there a debate about whether Scott Pilgrim is anime or not?

—The debate arises from the ongoing discussion about the criteria for determining what is considered anime. Some argue that only shows made in Japan for the Japanese market qualify as anime, while others believe that international co-productions that involve Japanese talent and are influenced by anime should also be included.

Does the distinction between co-productions and outsourced cartoons make sense?

—The distinction between co-productions and outsourced cartoons is arbitrary and can be subjective. It relies on assumptions about the level of creative input from the Japanese side and the target market. This distinction has led to inconsistencies in defining what qualifies as anime.

Should shows like Scott Pilgrim be included in the anime database?

—Yes, shows like Scott Pilgrim that involve notable Japanese industry talent and are intended to reach a Japanese audience should be included in the anime database. Excluding them limits the representation of significant works and overlooks the influence of Japanese animation techniques and storytelling in international productions.

How can the definition of anime be expanded to be more inclusive?

—The definition of anime can be expanded by considering cultural context, production process, and artistic style rather than strict categorizations based on target market or creative input. An inclusive approach acknowledges the diversity and evolving nature of anime as a global phenomenon.

00:00Scott Pilgrim takes off is a true anime made in Japan with the intent to reach a Japanese audience.

03:30The distinction between co-productions and outsourced cartoons in defining what qualifies as anime is vague and arbitrary.

06:10Excluding co-productions from the anime database causes problems and limits the representation of significant works in the industry.

09:40The Western fandom's perception of anime often overlooks the intentions and contributions of Japanese industry talent.

12:00A more inclusive approach should be taken in defining anime, considering cultural context, production process, and artistic style.