The Pain of Inaccurate Violin Playing in Movies

TLDRIn this video, TwoSet Violin discusses the frustration they feel when watching movies that feature inaccurate violin playing. They critique specific scenes from a recent movie called Chevalier and highlight the mistakes made by the actors. TwoSet emphasizes the importance of hiring musicians or providing proper training to actors who play violin in movies.

Key insights

🎻Actors in movies often struggle to play the violin accurately, leading to cringe-inducing performances.

🤦‍♂️Common mistakes include incorrect bowing techniques, improper hand positions, and inaccurate intonation.

🎬TwoSet Violin suggests that hiring violinists or providing proper training to actors would result in more authentic and enjoyable performances.

🎶The duo encourages filmmakers to accurately depict the art of violin playing to avoid frustrating musicians and audiences.

👍TwoSet Violin urges viewers to support accurate portrayals of violin playing by liking and subscribing to their channel.

Q&A

Why do actors struggle to play the violin accurately in movies?

Acting is a challenging skill, and playing the violin is equally challenging. It takes years of practice and dedication to become proficient. Actors often have limited time to learn the basics, resulting in inaccurate performances.

What are some common mistakes made by actors playing the violin?

Common mistakes include holding the bow incorrectly, improper hand positions, using excessive vibrato, and playing with poor intonation. These mistakes can be jarring for trained musicians and knowledgeable audiences.

How can filmmakers improve the accuracy of violin playing in movies?

Filmmakers can improve accuracy by hiring professional violinists or providing proper training to actors. This way, they can create more authentic and believable performances that resonate with musicians and audiences alike.

Why is it important to accurately depict violin playing in movies?

Accurate depictions of violin playing show respect for the art form and the hard work violinists put into their craft. It allows audiences to appreciate the beauty of the violin and avoids frustrating musicians who are knowledgeable about the instrument.

How can viewers support accurate portrayals of violin playing?

Viewers can support accurate portrayals of violin playing by liking and subscribing to channels like TwoSet Violin, who advocate for authenticity and proper representation in movies. Supporting educational content creators helps raise awareness and encourage change in the industry.

Timestamped Summary

00:00TwoSet Violin discusses the frustration of watching movies with inaccurate violin playing.

01:02They express their desire to see more accurate portrayals of violin playing in movies.

01:35TwoSet Violin critiques specific scenes from the movie Chevalier.

05:00They highlight common mistakes made by actors, including incorrect bowing techniques and improper hand positions.

07:15TwoSet Violin shares their disappointment with the inaccuracies in the movie's portrayal of a violinist's technique.

09:18They criticize the use of jazz elements in classical music scenes, calling it inaccurate and borderline racist.

11:23TwoSet Violin encourages viewers to support accurate portrayals of violin playing by liking and subscribing to their channel.