The Controversy Over the Hip Drop Tackle: Injury Analysis and Discussion

🤕The injury sustained by Mark Andrews is likely a high ankle sprain or syndesmosis tear, possibly requiring surgery and ending his season.

❗️The hip drop tackle, as seen in the video, involves a player sliding through and pulling the opponent down from behind, potentially causing ankle and foot injuries.

⚖️Banning the hip drop tackle may reduce the risk of injuries, but it may also limit players' ability to effectively tackle in certain situations.

🏈Understanding the mechanics of the tackle and the positioning of the players can help distinguish intent from natural tackling techniques.

🗣Dr. Brian Sud invites audience opinions on the hip drop tackle, whether it should be banned, and whether players can change their tackling techniques to make the game safer.

What is the likely injury Mark Andrews suffered?

—Mark Andrews likely suffered a high ankle sprain or syndesmosis tear. A complete tear of the high ankle sprain ligament would require surgery and end his season.

What is the hip drop tackle?

—The hip drop tackle is a tackling technique where a player slides through and pulls the opponent down from behind. It can potentially cause ankle and foot injuries.

Should the hip drop tackle be banned?

—There is a debate about whether the hip drop tackle should be banned. While it may reduce the risk of injuries, it may also limit players' ability to effectively tackle in certain situations.

Was there intent to injure in the hip drop tackle?

—In the analyzed play, it appears that there was no intent to injure in the hip drop tackle. The player was trying to bring the opponent down using the natural techniques of tackling.

Can players change their tackling techniques?

—Players can learn and adapt their tackling techniques to make the game safer. However, certain instincts and situations may make it challenging to completely eliminate the hip drop tackle.

00:12Ravens' Mark Andrews likely suffered a season-ending high ankle sprain or syndesmosis tear.

02:11The hip drop tackle involves sliding through and pulling the opponent down from behind.

03:10Banning the hip drop tackle can reduce injuries, but it may limit players' tackling techniques.

04:36Understanding the mechanics and intent behind a tackle can help evaluate its safety.

05:41Dr. Brian Sud invites audience opinions on the hip drop tackle and its potential ban.