The Case of Marcius vs Ayala: Who's Responsible for the Pencil Incident?

🖊️Alina is suing Sandra Ayala, the mother of her son's schoolmate, for the cost of her son's medical bills after he was injured with a pencil.

💼The judge holds Sandra responsible for the medical bills, even though Jonathan claims it was an accident.

🌐Nathaniel, Alina's son, sat on the chair with the pencil, causing it to go into his buttocks and require surgical removal.

💸Alina and Sandra were dating and Alina made several loans to Sandra, but he never paid her back.

🙅Sandra claimed that the loans were part of a normal dating relationship, but Alina argues that he promised to pay her back.

Why is Alina suing Sandra?

—Alina is suing Sandra for the cost of her son's medical bills after he was injured with a pencil.

Why is Sandra being held responsible for the medical bills?

—Despite Jonathan's claim that it was an accident, the judge holds Sandra responsible for the medical bills.

What happened to Nathaniel?

—Nathaniel sat on a chair with a pencil, causing it to go into his buttocks and require surgical removal.

Did Sandra ever pay back the loans?

—No, Sandra never paid back the loans that Alina made to him.

What is Sandra's defense for not paying back the loans?

—Sandra claimed that the loans were part of a normal dating relationship and he didn't have to pay them back.

00:00Alina is suing Sandra Ayala for the cost of her son's medical bills after he was injured with a pencil.

02:30Alina claims that Nathaniel sat on a chair with a pencil, causing it to go into his buttocks and require surgical removal.

04:40Sandra argued that the loans were part of a normal dating relationship and he didn't have to pay them back.

06:40The judge holds Sandra responsible for the medical bills, even though Jonathan claims the pencil incident was an accident.