Chapter 41-42 of Great Expectations: Pip's Dilemma and Magwitch's Past

TLDRPip is torn between wanting to separate himself from Magwitch and not wanting him to go back to prison. Herbert suggests taking Magwitch out of the country. Magwitch tells Pip the story of his rough life. Herbert reveals that Miss Havisham's lover was a swindler named Arthur.

Key insights

💔Pip is conflicted about his relationship with Magwitch and fears the consequences of separating from him.

🌍Herbert suggests taking Magwitch out of the country as a solution to Pip's dilemma.

🔒Magwitch recounts his tough life, growing up in poverty and being in and out of jail.

🤯Magwitch's partner in crime, Compeyson, swindled Miss Havisham and was known as Arthur.

💔Pip learns that Miss Havisham's lover, Arthur, was the same person who swindled her.

Q&A

Why does Pip want to separate from Magwitch?

Pip is torn between his gratitude for what Magwitch has done for him and his fear of getting involved in criminal activities.

What solution does Herbert propose to Pip?

Herbert suggests taking Magwitch out of the country to avoid further legal complications in England.

What is Magwitch's background?

Magwitch grew up in poor circumstances, faced rejection and spent his youth in and out of jail.

Who is Miss Havisham's lover?

Miss Havisham's lover was a swindler named Arthur, who later became a partner in crime with Magwitch.

What shocking revelation does Herbert make?

Herbert reveals that Miss Havisham's lover, Arthur, was the same person who swindled her and professed to be in love with her.

Timestamped Summary

00:09Pip is torn between separating from Magwitch and wanting to protect him from going back to prison.

00:52Herbert suggests taking Magwitch out of the country as a solution to Pip's dilemma.

00:55Magwitch recounts his tough life, growing up in poverty and being in and out of jail.

02:12Herbert reveals that Miss Havisham's lover, Arthur, was a swindler named Compeyson.

02:25Pip learns that Miss Havisham's lover, Arthur, was the same person who swindled her and professed to be in love with her.