A Tale of Two Cities: Book 2 Chapter 3 Summary

TLDRIn Book 2 Chapter 3 of A Tale of Two Cities, Charles Darnay is on trial for treason. John Barsad accuses him of spying and providing information to the French monarchy. Lucie and Dr. Manette confirm Darnay's presence on a ferry, but Lucie feels conflicted about testifying. Mr. Stryver defends Darnay by casting doubt on Barsad's testimony. The jury retires to make a decision. Darnay believes he will be convicted, but his life is ultimately saved by his resemblance to Sydney Carton. The chapter explores themes of resurrection, self-sacrifice, and injustice.

Key insights

🎭The physical resemblance between Sydney Carton and Charles Darnay becomes crucial in saving Darnay's life during the trial.

🔒Lucie feels conflicted about testifying against Darnay due to her belief in his innocence and her genuine feelings for him.

⚖️Mr. Stryver defends Darnay by questioning the reliability of Barsad's testimony and suggesting that Darnay's appearance could easily be mistaken for Carton's.

🔮This chapter foreshadows future events in the novel and highlights the theme of resurrection, as Darnay narrowly escapes a potentially fatal conviction.

🚫Barsad and Cly attempt to frame Darnay, using his aristocratic background to make him vulnerable to false accusations and divert attention from their own spying activities.

Q&A

What is the main conflict in this chapter?

The main conflict in this chapter is Charles Darnay's trial for treason and the accusation that he has been spying for the French monarchy.

How does Lucie feel about testifying against Darnay?

Lucie feels conflicted about testifying against Darnay. While she believes in his innocence, she is also aware of the potential consequences for him if she speaks out.

How does Mr. Stryver defend Darnay?

Mr. Stryver defends Darnay by questioning the reliability of John Barsad's testimony and highlighting the resemblance between Darnay and Sydney Carton.

What does this chapter foreshadow?

This chapter foreshadows future events and themes in the novel, particularly the theme of resurrection and the importance of physical resemblance.

What role do Barsad and Cly play in the trial?

Barsad and Cly attempt to frame Darnay by accusing him of spying. They use his aristocratic background to make him susceptible to false accusations.

Timestamped Summary

00:00[Music]

00:09Book 2 Chapter 3 of A Tale of Two Cities is called 'A Disappointment.'

00:15Charles Darnay is on trial for treason at the Old Bailey.

00:23John Barsad accuses Darnay of spying for the French monarchy and providing lists of England's troops and movements.

00:35Mr. Jarvis Lorry testifies that Darnay was on a ferry with him, confirming Barsad's claim.

01:10Mr. Stryver defends Darnay by questioning Barsad's ability to identify him and highlighting the resemblance between Darnay and Sydney Carton.

01:43The jury retires to make a decision.

01:53Lucie feels conflicted about testifying against Darnay and becomes distraught.